If you love pencil eyeliner, you've probably been through the same struggle as me when it comes to finding one that doesn't smudge, bleed or disappear from your waterline after only a couple of hours.

If you're a fan of pencil eyeliner, you'll know the struggle of finding one that doesn't smudge, bleed or vanish from your waterline after just a few hours. Whether it's a high-end brand with a ...

eyeliners are usually makeup staples. From gel liners to cream liners and liquid liners to pencil liners — and more — it can ...